Chapter 3 - The Gaslight Strategy
By five o'clock that afternoon, snow was falling heavily across the Chicago skyline, turning Michigan Avenue into a quiet blanket of white. Inside Attorney Harold Vance’s wood-paneled office, the heat hummed softly against the floorboards.
Harold sat behind a large mahogany desk, reviewing the stack of financial printouts Eleanor and I had brought him.
"You have a solid case for financial dissipation," Harold said, laying his pen down. "In Illinois, funds used to support an extramarital affair during the breakdown of the marriage can be reclaimed during property division. The lease payments, the jewelry, the hotel charges—Jonathan will have to reimburse you for every single dollar from his share of the marital estate."
"I don't just want the money back, Harold," I said, my voice steady. "I want full ownership of our home, and I want him served before the holidays end."
"We can file emergency motion papers on December twenty-sixth," Harold replied. "However, Clara, you must remain careful. Jonathan will realize very soon that his mother isn't backing him. When he feels the trap close, he will try to manipulate you directly."
His warning proved prophetic less than thirty minutes later.
As Eleanor and I rode the elevator down to the parking garage, my phone rang. It was Jonathan.
Eleanor gave me a firm nod. "Answer it. Put him on speaker. Say as little as possible."
I pressed the screen. "Hello, Jonathan."
"Clara! Thank God," Jonathan’s voice rushed through the speaker, breathless and artificially frantic. "I’ve been trying to reach you all day. Where are you? Why aren't you at my parents' house?"
"I’m out with your mother," I said coolly.
Jonathan let out a loud, theatrical sigh. "Look, Clara, about yesterday... I know how that looked at the mall. It looked terrible, and I completely understand why you were confused and upset."
Confused. The word made my stomach turn. He was already trying to rewrite reality, framing my clear sight of his infidelity as mere confusion.
"I wasn't confused, Jonathan. I saw you holding her hand."
"She was having an anxiety attack!" Jonathan snapped, his tone instantly shifting from pleading to sharp irritation. "Samantha’s ex-husband threatened her custody rights yesterday morning! She was practically hysterical, Clara! I ran into her at the mall, she grabbed my arm because she was dizzy, and I was trying to calm her down! You're making this into a trashy scandal because you refuse to listen to context!"
I looked at Eleanor. She closed her eyes slowly, shaking her head in disgusted disbelief.
"And the charcoal coat?" I asked quietly. "Did she need to lean on that too?"
"You are being completely unreasonable!" Jonathan yelled through the phone. "I’m trying to be a good person and help an old friend who has nobody else in this city! And instead of supporting me, you're hiding out with my mother and turning my family against me! Do you have any idea how stressed I am at work right now?!"
It was textbook gaslighting. He was attempting to make his betrayal my fault for lacking empathy toward his mistress.
"We were supposed to have dinner at seven, Jonathan," I said, ignoring his outburst. "Are you coming to your parents' house or not?"
A brief pause hovered over the line. Jonathan’s confidence wobbled slightly. "Is Dad there?"
"He will be," I replied.
"Fine," Jonathan growled. "I’ll be there at seven. And I expect you to act like an adult so we can resolve this like civilized people."
He slammed the phone down.
I stared at the black screen, feeling a strange, cold calm settle over my heart. The sadness that had threatened to drown me all morning was gone, replaced by a crystalline, unshakeable clarity.
May you like
"He thinks he’s coming to a negotiation," I said to Eleanor as we walked toward her car.
"Let him think that," Eleanor replied, unlocking the doors. "It makes the fall so much sweeter."
