Chapter 5 - The Ledger of Mistakes
The atmosphere inside Rose & Rye was usually a comfort—the warm smell of yeast, cinnamon, and roasting coffee beans normally acted as a shield against the rest of the world. But today, every ringing bell above the entrance door made my heart leap into my throat.
At 11:00 AM, during the quiet lull between the breakfast rush and the lunch crowd, the bell chimed once more.
I was standing behind the glass display case, organizing a fresh tray of almond croissants, when the scent reached me first—a subtle, familiar blend of sandalwood and rain.
I looked up. Nathan walked into the bakery.
He had cleaned himself up. He wore a crisp white shirt, a dark charcoal suit, and his hair was brushed back, though the exhaustion in his eyes remained intact. He didn't look like a customer; he looked like a man entering a courtroom to hear his final sentence.
My assistant, a young college student named Lily, stepped up to the register. “Welcome to Rose & Rye! What can I get for you today?”
“He’s with me, Lily,” I said quietly, wiping my flour-dusted hands on my apron. “Take your break early. Go grab a coffee down the street.”
Lily looked between the two of us, sensing the thick, suffocating tension in the room, nodded quickly, and slipped out the back door.
Nathan walked slowly toward the counter, looking around the bright, cozy shop with a bittersweet smile. He touched the polished maple wood of the counter, his fingers lingering on the handcrafted details.
“You built this,” he said, awe laced through his quiet tone. “You always talked about opening a little pastry shop in Evanston... I never took the time to help you look at floor plans. I was always too busy with the corporate mergers.”
“I didn't need your help,” I said, standing tall on the other side of the counter. “I needed a husband who was faithful. I built this place with my own hard work.”
Nathan closed his eyes, accepting the sharp blow without defense. “I know.”
He reached inside his leather briefcase, pulled out a thick, faded leather-bound notebook, and placed it on the counter between us.
“What is that?” I asked, staring at the worn black leather.
“Four years of letters,” Nathan said softly. “Every single day since the night you walked out of the Grand Plaza Hotel, I wrote to you. When your mother refused to accept my calls, when the investigators came up empty, I kept writing. Because it was the only way I could keep from losing my mind.”
He pushed the notebook toward me.
“You don't have to read it now,” he said. “You don't ever have to read it if you don't want to. But inside that book is the truth about Chloe Bennett.”
At the mention of her name, a cold shudder ran through my veins. “I don't care about Chloe Bennett.”
“You need to know, Clara!” Nathan insisted, his voice breaking as he stepped closer to the counter, his palms pressing against the glass. “I never touched her before that night. Never. She was an associate whose father sat on my board. She pushed her way into my office after hours, half-drunk, threatening to have her father pull his investment if I didn't promote her. I was trying to push her off me—I was literally grabbing her wrists to shove her away when you stepped into that doorway!”
I stared at him, my heart freezing solid. “Is that supposed to make it better, Nathan? You let her into your office. You let her smell like perfume on your collars for months before that! You called me dramatic every time I brought up my suspicions! You made me feel like I was losing my mind!”
“Because I was a coward!” Nathan cried out, tears spilling down his face. “I was arrogant, I was consumed by my own ego, and I took you for granted every single day! I thought you would always be there! I thought no matter how detached I became, you would stay!”
He dropped his head, his tears dripping onto the glass display case.
May you like
“I destroyed the only good thing I ever owned in this world,” he sobbed quietly. “And I’m not asking you to take me back, Clara. I know I lost you forever. But please... don't punish our sons for my sin. Don't deprive them of a father who would tear down the sky just to give them everything they ever needed.”
I stared at the black notebook sitting on the counter. The air in the bakery was heavy, suffocating, thick with four years of unresolved grief and sudden, agonizing choices.
