Chapter 2 - The Alibi

Blake didn’t flinch. He didn’t curse. He simply read Carrie Holland’s affidavit a second time, analyzing every word with the detached precision of an attorney dissecting an adversary’s fatal error.
"Look at paragraph four," Blake said, tapping the bond paper with his pen. "Carrie states that she personally witnessed this supposed incident at my home in Lake Forest at approximately seven-thirty in the evening on Wednesday, November twelfth."
Marcus leaned forward, a grim smile touching the corner of his mouth. "Where were you on November twelfth, Blake?"
"I was in Indianapolis at the Birch Bayh Federal Building," Blake said. "Arguing the preliminary injunction in the *Midwest Logistics* antitrust litigation. The hearing ran late into the evening. Judge Hamilton held us in the courtroom until eight-fifteen PM. Then I had dinner with opposing counsel, Arthur Vance, and three junior associates at the Capital Grille until ten."
"Receipts?" Marcus asked.
"Itemized corporate American Express bill, court transcript with official time stamps, hotel keycard logs from the Conrad Indianapolis, and dashboard camera footage from my rental car," Blake said without missing a beat. "And more importantly, the court reporter signed the transcript under federal seal."
Marcus leaned back in his leather executive chair, letting out a low breath. "They got careless. They assumed you’d be so terrified of losing custody that you'd panic, negotiate, and accept a joint-parenting agreement that protects Vera's reputation."
"They don't understand who they're dealing with," Blake said. "Eleanor Holland has spent thirty years bullying country club committees, local charity boards, and her pushover husband. She thinks the judicial system runs on social influence and polished lies."
"We can file for immediate sanctions," Marcus suggested. "Perjury referrals to the Lake County State's Attorney."
"Not yet," Blake replied. "If we reveal the Indianapolis alibi now, Carrie will file an amended affidavit claiming she got the date wrong. She'll say it was a clerical error, a typo made by her paralegal, and the court will give her a slap on the wrist. We hold this. We let Eleanor, Vera, and Carrie dig their graves so deep they can't climb out."
Blake left Marcus’s office and drove back toward the extended-stay suite. On the drive, his phone rang through the car’s Bluetooth system. The caller ID flashed: *Dick Holland.*
Blake pressed the steering wheel button. "Blake Carlson."
"Blake, son, let’s be reasonable about this," Dick’s voice came through the speakers, hearty and calculatedly genial, the voice he used when trying to sell distressed commercial real estate. "Things got out of hand on Saturday. Vera was stressed. You know how she gets when she plans big social events. The dress was an heirloom silk piece her grandmother gave her."
"Dick," Blake said, his tone icy, "your daughter left a six-year-old child outside in twenty-six-degree weather without a coat. When I found him, his body temperature was ninety-four degrees. If I had stayed in Milwaukee another hour, Ethan would be in a pediatric intensive care unit—or a morgue."
"Oh, come on, that’s hyperbolic," Dick scoffed, though his voice wavered slightly. "The boy is fine. Kids are resilient. Look, you come home tonight, we sit down over a scotch, we tear up these ridiculous legal filings, and we handle this within the family. Eleanor is willing to overlook your little outburst at the party."
Blake gripped the steering wheel until his knuckles whitened. "Did you read Carrie’s affidavit, Dick?"
A brief pause. "Family stands together, Blake. That’s how the Hollands operate. You push us, and we push back ten times harder. You’re an outsider here. You came from public schools and state universities. Eleanor has judges who play bridge at our club every Saturday. If you take this to a Lake County courtroom, we will ruin your reputation. You’ll never practice law in this state again."
"Are you threatening me, Dick?"
"I'm giving you a reality check," Dick replied. "Drop the petition. Bring Ethan back to the house. Let Vera have primary physical custody, and we'll grant you standard weekend visitation. Otherwise, things are going to get very ugly for you."
Blake took a quiet breath. "Dick, tell Eleanor to buy a good criminal defense lawyer. She's going to need one."
Blake hung up.
When he unlocked the hotel suite door, the savory scent of roasted chicken filled the air. Ethan was sitting at the low coffee table, carefully drawing with colored pencils on a pad of sketch paper. A small, blue toy dragon sat beside him.
"Daddy!" Ethan dropped his pencil and ran toward Blake, wrapping his arms around Blake's waist.
Blake hugged him tightly, breathing in the scent of baby shampoo and fresh laundry. "Hey, buddy. What are you working on?"
Ethan led him to the table. On the paper was a drawing of a small boy standing inside a giant glass bubble, surrounded by fierce, snarling gray wolves. Outside the bubble stood a tall man in a dark suit holding a glowing blue shield.
"That's you," Ethan pointed to the man with the shield. "You keep the cold out."
Blake felt an ache deep in his chest. "Nobody is going to hurt you, Ethan. Ever again."
Ethan looked down at his sneakers, fidgeting with the edge of his sleeve. "Aunt Carrie came to school on Monday before you picked me up."
Blake went utterly rigid. He kept his voice soft, almost conversational. "Aunt Carrie came to school?"
"She waited by the playground fence during recess," Ethan said in a quiet, cautious voice, as if afraid he was breaking a rule. "She waved at me and gave me a candy bar through the bars. She told me to tell the judge that you yell a lot."
Blake knelt beside the table. "What else did she say, Ethan?"
"She said if I told the police that Mommy was mean, they would put Mommy in a cage, and it would be my fault." Tears welled in the boy's large eyes. "She said good boys don't tell on their mommies."
Blake reached out and gently rested his hand on his son’s shoulder. The Hollands had crossed every boundary of basic human decency. They were actively tampering with a six-year-old witness.
"Ethan, look at me," Blake said, his gaze unwavering. "Nothing that happened is your fault. Not the juice. Not the cold. Not Mommy’s anger. You are never in trouble for telling the truth. Do you understand me?"
Ethan nodded slowly, wiping his eyes with the back of his hand.
Blake stood up, walked into the kitchenette, and pulled out his phone. He dialed Ray Vance, a former Chicago police detective who now ran the premier digital forensics and private investigation firm in the Midwest.
"Ray," Blake said. "It’s Blake Carlson."
"Blake. What do you need?"
"I need full forensic extraction on my home security systems, smart locks, and internal environmental sensors. I need street-level surveillance on my son's school. And I need a forensic accountant to audit my personal and marital bank accounts immediately."
"Sounds like war," Ray observed.
May you like
"It's not war, Ray," Blake replied, his eyes cold and resolved. "It's an execution."
***