forum

Chapter 4 - The Sound of Florence

The bell of the Basilica di Santa Maria del Fiore did not click like my hall clock. It rolled across the terracotta roofs of Florence like thunder captured in bronze, vibrating through the stone floor beneath my shoes and through the glass of red wine sitting on the cafe table before me.

It was four in the afternoon. The light was that particular Tuscan gold that makes everything—even the exhaust from the passing Vespas—look like a painting from the late Renaissance.

My phone sat on the marble tabletop next to a plate of green olives and a dish of shaved pecorino.

It had been thirty-six hours since I stepped into Arthur’s shuttle. During that time, the screen had illuminated ninety-four times.

*Twelve missed calls from Caleb.*

*Six missed calls from Tori.*

*Seventy-two text messages.*

*Four voice notes.*

I took a sip of the wine. It was dry, slightly acidic, and cost six euros. It was the most delicious thing I had tasted in five years.

I swiped open the message thread from Caleb.

*10:14 AM (Day 1): Mom, this is ridiculous. We are at home. Tori is beside herself. We lost $4,200 on the cancellation fees. Call us.*

*2:45 PM (Day 1): Where did you put Finn's allergy medication? It's not in the kitchen.*

*3:12 PM (Day 1): Never mind, found it in the guest bathroom. Eli says you told him to make shepherd's pie. Is there garlic in it? Tori has an intolerance.*

*8:30 PM (Day 1): Tori went back to the city office. She couldn't take being in the house. I'm here with all four. Eli won't talk to me. Mom, please answer.*

*7:15 AM (Day 2): Finn threw up cereal on Charles's rug. What do I use to get milk out of wool? Don't look at this and ignore it, Mom. That rug was Dad's.*

I tapped the screen and typed four words:

*Cold water and vinegar.*

I hit send.

Within six seconds, three gray dots appeared on the bottom of the screen, dancing with frantic, spastic energy.

*Caleb: Are you in Italy? Did you actually go?*

*Me: The Santa Croce quarter. The weather is sixty-two degrees.*

*Caleb: Tori is threatening to call her lawyer about the trip costs.*

I paused, setting my wine glass down. I looked out over the piazza. A group of school children in navy blue uniforms were chasing pigeons past the statue of Dante, their laughter sharp and clear in the cool October air. A young mother was wheeling a stroller with one hand while holding an espresso in the other, leaning down to speak to her child not with an eye on an Apple Watch, but with an open, unhurried face.

I picked up the phone again.

*Me: Tell Victoria that if she calls her lawyer, she should also ask him what the legal fee is for drafting an eviction notice. My house is not a community center. If she speaks to me in that tone again, the deadbolt will be changed before my flight lands in Newark.*

The dots danced. Then disappeared.

Then the phone rang.

I let it ring three times before sliding the green icon across the glass. "Hello, Caleb."

"Mom." His voice sounded hollowed out, scraped raw at the edges. Behind him, I could hear the unmistakable sound of a five-year-old beating a metal spoon against an overturned stockpot. "Maggie won't put her shoes on. She's been wearing one pink rain boot and one slipper for twelve hours. She bites when I try to take them off."

"She gets that from your aunt Clara," I said. "Clara bit three nurses when she broke her collarbone in nineteen-sixty-eight."

"Mom, I haven't slept," he whispered. "Tori is... she's working from the corner office. She says if we're not in Tokyo, she might as well bill eighty hours this week to make up for the lost revenue. She left me here alone with them."

"You are their father, Caleb."

"I don't know how to do this!" he burst out, his voice cracking with the exact same register he’d had at nine years old, standing by the broken jam jar. "Tori does the schedules. She has the color-coded spreadsheets. I don't know which bus Eli takes. I don't know what Finn eats when he's sad. Finn cried for an hour because the toast was cut into squares instead of triangles, and I couldn't remember which one he liked!"

"Triangles," I said softly. "The crusts come off easier that way."

A heavy, wet sniff came through the line. Caleb was crying. My son, the equity partner, the man who argued with tax assessors and managed municipal portfolios worth forty million dollars, was weeping over sliced sandwich bread in the kitchen his father had built.

"Why didn't you tell us, Mom?" he asked, his voice shaking. "Why didn't you just say you were going to Italy?"

"I did, Caleb."

"No, you didn't! We had no idea!"

"I told you on your birthday," I said, letting the words fall into the line with the weight of stones dropped into a well. "I told you while you were checking your work email between the soup and the salad. I told you that Charles and I had a fund, and that the voucher expired this autumn, and that I had booked the tour. You nodded, said 'That's great, Mom, make sure you get travel insurance,' and then you took a phone call about a bond issue in Cleveland."

The line went utterly silent. Even the spoon-beating in the background seemed to have paused.

"You don't listen, Caleb," I continued, looking up at the gray marble facade of the church across the square. "You hear noise, and you manage it. You manage your clients, you manage your associates, and you let your wife manage your family as if it were an underperforming branch office. But you do not listen. And you certainly do not look."

"Mom..."

"Finn likes triangles," I told him. "Chloe needs thirty minutes of quiet after three o'clock or she gets a headache behind her left eye; don't make her do the violin until five. Eli doesn't want to talk about his grades; he wants someone to ask him about the engine he’s trying to build out of lawnmower parts in the shed. And Maggie will take off the rain boot if you tell her it's time for the queen to inspect her toes."

A long pause.

"How do you know that about the lawnmower?" Caleb asked, his voice very small.

"Because I live here," I said. "And because I love them enough to pay attention without charging them five hundred dollars an hour for the privilege."

I didn't wait for him to respond. "My tour group is meeting at the Uffizi in twenty minutes. Do not call me again today, Caleb. If the house catches fire, dial nine-one-one. If you need clean towels, they are in the hall closet behind the cedar chest. And use the white vinegar on the wool rug. If you use soap, the stain will set forever."

May you like

I hung up, dropped two euros onto the brass saucer for the waiter, and stood up into the Tuscan sunlight.

***

Related Stories

Other posts