Chapter 5 - The Challenge at the Table
The roast beef was half-eaten, and two bottles of Cabernet had already been drained when Uncle Richard set his fork down with a loud clatter.
"I’m telling you, Lucas," Richard boomed, wiping his mouth with one of Serena’s mother’s antique linen napkins, "you ought to tear down that old detached garage in the back. Put in a swimming pool! A man with an estate like this needs a pool for the summer!"
Lucas smiled, clearly feeling the effects of the wine. He leaned back in his chair, draping an arm casually over the back. "Funny you mention that, Uncle Rich. I’ve actually been looking at some contractor estimates for the backyard. Thinking about putting in a plunge pool and a stone patio next spring."
Beatrice beamed with absolute pride. "Oh, it will be magnificent! My Lucas has such a vision for his home!"
Serena cut a single piece of asparagus on her plate. The silver knife made a sharp, clean sound against the porcelain.
"A pool, Lucas?" Serena asked, her voice quiet, clear, and perfectly carrying over the laughter at the table. "That’s interesting. Where are you planning to get the quarter-million dollars required for historic district excavation permissions and construction?"
The table grew slightly quiet. Lucas’s smile stiffened.
"Come on, Serena," Lucas said, chuckling nervously. "We’re just talking. No need to get technical."
"Oh, she always does this, Richard," Beatrice scoffed, waving her fork dismissively. "Whenever Lucas wants to make an improvement to his house, Serena finds a way to throw cold water on it. She has no vision for prosperity."
Aunt Martha nodded in agreement, taking a sip of her wine. "Well, men need room to build their legacy, dear. A wife should support her husband’s ambitions for his estate."
Serena set her knife and fork down side by side on her plate. She looked at Aunt Martha, then at Uncle Richard, then at Beatrice, before finally settling her gaze on Lucas.
"His estate?" Serena asked softly.
"Serena, drop it," Lucas warned under his breath, his eyes darting toward his relatives. "Not tonight."
"No, I’m genuinely curious, Lucas," Serena continued, her tone conversational, almost pleasant. "Your mother has used the phrase 'his house,' 'his property,' and 'his estate' four times since dinner started. You haven't corrected her once. So I want to understand what narrative you've been giving your family for the last two years."
Beatrice slammed her hand down on the table, making the wine glasses rattle. "That is enough, Serena! You will not speak to my son with such disrespect in his own dining room!"
"In his dining room?" Serena asked, raising an eyebrow.
"Yes! In his dining room!" Beatrice shouted, her face turning a mottled red. "Lucas is the head of this household! He works his fingers to the bone while you sit upstairs playing on your computer! He allows you to live in this magnificent home, and you treat him—and his mother—like unwanted guests!"
Uncle Richard shifted uncomfortably in his seat. Even Todd looked up from his phone, sensing the sudden spike in tension.
"Mom, please..." Lucas stammered, his face pale now, the alcohol-induced bravado draining out of him instantly. "Mom, stop—"
"No, Lucas! I will not stop!" Beatrice snapped, standing up from her chair to tower over the table. "She has been cold and ungrateful to me since the day I moved in! She complained about the air-conditioning! She complained about me redecorating! She acts as if she owns the place!"
Serena sat completely still. Her heart was beating with a slow, powerful rhythm.
"Beatrice," Serena said, her voice dropping an octave into a tone of absolute, chilling authority. "Are you under the impression that Lucas owns this property?"
"Of course he owns it!" Beatrice sneered, pointing a finger at Serena’s face. "He is a Miller! He is the provider here! You are just his wife!"
Serena looked at Lucas.
"Tell her," Serena said.
Lucas swallowed hard. "Serena, please... we can talk about this later—"
"Tell her who really owns this house, Lucas," Serena commanded, her voice cutting through the heavy dining room air like an executioner's blade. "Tell your mother right now. In front of your uncle, your aunt, and your cousin. Tell her whose name is on the deed."
The dining room fell into a dead, suffocating silence.
Beatrice laughed—a sharp, confident sound that died quickly when she saw the look of sheer, unadulterated terror on her son’s face.
May you like
"Lucas?" Beatrice asked, her voice faltering slightly as she looked down at him. "Lucas, what is she talking about?"
Lucas couldn't lift his head. He stared fixatedly at the stain on his napkin, his lips trembling, his chest heaving as the walls of his elaborate, two-year fantasy crumbled into absolute dust.
