Chapter 2 - The Footage

I tapped the video thumbnail with a trembling thumb. The audio blasted through the quiet bedroom before I could hit the volume rocker, filling Rachel’s guest room with the clinking of champagne flutes and laughter.
"Shh," I whispered, glancing at Fiona. She didn't stir, her thumb tucked securely into her mouth. I brought the phone close to my ear.
Kelly’s video started thirty seconds before the slap. The phone camera had been angled behind a massive floral arrangement, capturing the entire center of the head table. Wendy was standing up, holding her glass, her face flushed with wine. She wasn't just making a toast—she was delivering a tirade.
"And to my son, Luca," Wendy’s sharp, piercing voice echoed from the tiny speaker, "who unfortunately brought an outsider into this family. An outsider who thinks she can control our bloodline."
Luca was on the screen, leaning back in his chair with a tight, pathetic smile on his face, nodding along as if his mother were simply cracking a cute joke. Beside him, Fiona had reached for a bread roll on the formal silver tray. Her small fingers knocked over a glass of iced tea, sending a wave of brown liquid across the white linen tablecloth.
The video captured every frame in horrific clarity.
Wendy didn't just snap. She moved with deliberate, calculated venom. She lunged across her seat, grabbed Fiona by her upper arm, yanked the toddler toward her, and delivered a full-force backhand across her cheek. The sound of the slap echoed like a gunshot through the restaurant room.
Then came the words: "You useless piece of trash, this girl has defective genetics!"
The camera shook violently as Kelly gasped, but it caught what happened next in brutal detail. Luca didn't move. He literally flinched, grabbed his fork, and stared straight down into his bowl of beef stew as if he were trying to blend into the furniture.
Then I entered the frame.
I watched myself move with a speed I didn't know I possessed. I reached across the table, caught Luca across the jaw with an open palm—sending his thick-framed glasses flying in an arc straight into his broth—and grabbed Wendy by her pearl necklace, shoving her backward with enough momentum to send her tumbling straight into her three-tiered red velvet birthday cake. Red frosting exploded across her hair, her face, and her silk blouse.
"You're thirty years old and still can't defend your own child!" my voice roared through the speaker before I snatched Fiona up and walked out of the frame.
The video didn't end there. Kelly had kept recording.
With me gone, the room was dead silent save for Wendy's hysterical shrieks as she tried to wipe red cake out of her eyes.
"Luca!" Wendy screamed in the recording, her voice shrill and manic. "Look what she did to me! She’s crazy! She’s going to take your money! Call the police! Call Richard!"
Then came Luca’s voice. It wasn't the voice of a panicked husband trying to save his marriage. It was cold, calculating, and eerily calm.
"Don't call the police yet, Mom," Luca said on the tape, leaning over to wipe broth off his collar with a napkin. "If she leaves tonight, she broke the peace first. We can use this. We can say she’s unstable. We can get sole custody of Fiona before she even finds a lawyer."
My heart stopped. The room felt like it ran out of oxygen instantly.
I stared at the screen, replaying those fifteen seconds five times. We can say she’s unstable. We can get sole custody.
He hadn't run out to the parking lot to apologize. He hadn't come out to check on his daughter. He had come out to test whether I was hysterical enough to build a legal case against me.
Kelly sent another message: "I sent this to you from a burner account. Luca told everyone at the table to delete their recordings. He’s telling his family you attacked Wendy unprovoked because of a post-partum breakdown. Save this file to an external drive right now."
I typed back: "Why are you giving me this, Kelly?"
Kelly replied instantly: "Because my aunt Wendy is a monster, my cousin is a coward, and I saw what she did to that baby's face. Don't let them destroy you, Jessi."
I downloaded the file to three separate cloud drives, backed it up to a flash drive in my purse, and closed my eyes.
For two years, I had thought Luca was just weak. I had thought he was a mama's boy who couldn't break the umbilical cord, a soft man raised by a domineering matriarch. I had pitied him. I had tried to help him find his spine.
I was wrong. Luca wasn't weak. He was his mother's son through and through. He was a predator in a soft cardigan, waiting for the right moment to strip me of my child so Wendy could raise Fiona under her complete control.
Rachel knocked softly on the door frame, carrying two mugs of tea. She took one look at my face and set the mugs down on the dresser.
"What is it?" Rachel asked.
"They're going to try to take Fiona," I said, my voice eerily calm. "They're going to claim I had a mental breakdown."
Rachel sat beside me on the bed, her face turning dark. "They don't have a leg to stand on, Jessi. She hit a toddler."
"Wendy’s brother is Richard Vance," I said, remembering the name Wendy had shrieked in the video. "He’s the senior partner at Vance, Sterling & Howe. He sits on the municipal judicial board. They have money, they have judges, and they have thirty family members ready to sign affidavits saying I went crazy at a birthday party."
Rachel looked at me, her jaw tight. "Then what are you going to do?"
I looked at my sleeping daughter, touching the light red outline on her cheek. The fear that had been fluttering in my chest for the last two hours completely dissolved, replaced by a cold, sharp, crystal-clear focus.
"My mother left me three things when she died," I said softly to Rachel. "A house in Evanston, a trust fund Luca knows nothing about... and her old law school roommate."
May you like
"Who?" Rachel asked.
"Evelyn Cross," I said. "The meanest divorce attorney in the state of Illinois."