Chapter 6 - The Broken Pieces
Before Harold and I could finalize our logistics, I needed to know the full truth of what had happened in this house before I intercepted the airline’s call.
I walked back up to the loft. Tyler and Connor were downstairs now, helping their dad bring in firewood, leaving Lily and Max alone in the quiet reading nook by the high window.
I pulled up an armchair and sat down in front of them. The mountain sun was reflecting brightly off the snowbanks outside, casting long, clean beams of light across the timber floor.
“Hey,” I said softly.
Lily looked up from her sketchbook. She had been drawing a picture of an upright piano with tiny, crooked keys. Max was leaning against her side, tracing the pattern of the wood grain on the coffee table.
“Grandma left, didn't she?” Lily asked.
“She did,” I replied. “She’s staying at a hotel, and she won't be joining us for the rest of the trip.”
Max looked at his sneakers. “Because she doesn't like us.”
The bluntness of it knocked the breath out of me. I slid out of the chair and sat flat on the floor so I was eye-level with both of them.
“Max. Look at me, buddy.”
He looked up, his big brown eyes rimmed with red.
“Grandma has a sickness in her heart,” I said, speaking slowly and clearly. “It has nothing to do with whether you are good, or smart, or kind. You and Lily are the best things that have ever happened to this family. You are loving, you are respectful, and you are wonderful just the way you are. Grandma wanted you to be afraid of her because she thinks being feared is the same thing as being loved. But they aren't the same thing at all.”
Lily set her colored pencil down. Her fingers were trembling slightly.
“Dad?” she whispered.
“Yeah, Lil?”
“On Christmas Eve… while you were out getting groceries with Uncle Mark… Grandma came into our room.”
My stomach dropped into a cold, bottomless pit. I kept my voice perfectly level. “What did she say, sweetheart?”
Lily swallowed hard, glancing at Max as if protecting him from the memory. “She saw that Max had his shoes on the bed while he was reading. She snatched his book away and threw it into the corner.”
I felt the blood roar in my ears, but I didn't interrupt.
“And then,” Lily continued, her voice dropping to a fragile, frightened whisper, “she leaned over my bed and told me that Santa only comes to children who know their place. She said that Mama would have been ashamed of me for asking questions all the time. She told me that if I didn't learn to keep my mouth shut and obey without thinking, nobody would ever love me when I grew up.”
A suffocating silence descended on the loft.
Max reached out and grabbed Lily’s hand. “I told her Lily was the best big sister in the world,” Max whispered, his chin trembling. “And Grandma told me I was going to end up in a home for bad boys if I didn't learn to respect my elders.”
I sat on that floor, looking at my two precious children, and for a fleeting second, I wanted to walk down the road to that Marriott and tear the building apart with my bare hands.
The depth of Carol’s psychological cruelty wasn't an impulse; it was a targeted campaign designed to dismantle the spirits of two grieving children who had already lost their mother. She had weaponized Sarah’s memory. She had tried to poison Lily’s self-worth before the girl had even hit middle school.
I reached out, gathered both of them into my arms, and held them against my chest until I could feel their breathing sync with mine.
“Listen to me,” I whispered into their hair, my voice vibrating with absolute certainty. “Your mother loved your questions, Lily. She used to write down the things you asked in her journal because she said you had the mind of a scientist and the heart of a poet. She was proud of every single breath you took. And she would be furious at anyone who ever tried to make you feel small.”
Lily buried her face in my shoulder, and finally, the dam broke. She began to weep—deep, body-shaking sobs that released four days of terror, confusion, and suffocating guilt. Max wrapped his little arms around both of us, crying quietly into my sleeve.
I held them through the storm. I didn't tell them to stop crying. I didn't tell them to look on the bright side. I let them grieve the cruelty they had suffered until their tears slowed and their breathing steady.
After several minutes, footsteps sounded on the stairs.
Beth appeared at the landing, followed by twelve-year-old Connor and ten-year-old Tyler. Connor was carrying his brand-new Nintendo Switch in its sleek black case; Tyler was holding a massive box of specialized architectural LEGOs he had unwrapped on Christmas morning.
Connor looked at me, then at Lily, his face serious.
“Hey,” Connor said awkwardly, stepping into the loft. “Lily. Max.”
Lily wiped her cheeks with the back of her sleeve, looking up.
Connor walked over and set his brand-new Switch directly onto Lily’s lap. “You can have this. We can share it. I mean… you don't even have to share it. It’s yours.”
Tyler stepped forward and pushed his unopened, three-hundred-dollar LEGO set toward Max. “And you can build this, Max. I’ll help you with the hard parts. We don't care about what Grandma said. Grandma was being crazy.”
Max looked from the LEGO box to Tyler, his eyes wide. “Really?”
“Yeah,” Tyler said, sitting down cross-legged beside him. “Brothers and cousins stick together. That’s what Dad said.”
Beth stood at the top of the stairs, her hand over her mouth, fresh tears slipping down her cheeks. Mark stood behind her, his hand resting reassuringly on her shoulder.
I looked at my nephews, then at my sister, and felt the darkness in the room begin to break. Carol had tried to infect this family with her transactional, conditional poison, but the antidote had already taken root.
I stood up, kissed my kids once more, and turned toward Beth.
“Keep them here,” I said quietly. “Make hot chocolate. Put on the silliest movie you can find.”
“Where are you going, Austin?” Beth asked.
“The airline says the Kansas City cargo office closes their holiday freight division at 6:00 PM tomorrow,” I said, pulling my jacket off the hook. “United is running a weather ground-stop for commercial freight out of Missouri, so they can’t guarantee delivery back to Denver until after New Year’s.”
Grandpa Harold stepped up to the base of the stairs, holding his shearling coat and a heavy metal thermos of black coffee.
“So we aren't waiting on United,” Harold said, tossing me his truck keys. “Denver to Kansas City is nine hours through the plains if the roads stay clear. We leave now, we’re at the cargo warehouse by 8:00 AM tomorrow morning.”
I caught the keys in midair.
“Nine hours?” Beth asked, wide-eyed. “Through the Kansas flats in winter?”
Harold smiled—a wide, ferocious grin that made him look thirty years younger.
May you like
“Bethany, I drove supply convoys through the frozen hills of North Korea in fifty-one. A little Kansas snow ain't gonna stop me from getting my grandkids their Christmas.”
***
