Chapter 1 - The Breaking Point
Everyone clapped.
I put the metal spoon down on the plastic tray. The sharp *clink* was drowned out by the noise in my mother’s cramped dining room.
Bethany smiled across the table, her manicured fingers resting delicately over her flat stomach. "Surprise," she cooed, tilting her head with practiced innocence. "Baby number five."
Mom let out a high-pitched squeal, rushing around the table to envelop Bethany in an emotional embrace. Beside her, Travis—Bethany’s live-in boyfriend of eight months—leaned back in his chair, popped the cap off a fresh IPA with a lighter, and chuckled. "Told you I had good aim, babe."
I didn’t smile. I didn’t clap. I sat frozen between two-year-old Toby, who had strained carrots smeared across his chin, and seven-year-old Chloe, who was struggling through second-grade subtraction. Across from me sat four-year-old Leo, quietly lining up crusts of stale bread, and eleven-year-old Mason, whose dark eyes were fixed downward on his battered sneakers. Mason wasn’t clapping either. He knew what another baby meant.
For six years, I had been the ghost mother of this family.
I was twenty-eight. I worked forty-five hours a week as a medical billing specialist, yet my life wasn’t my own. I was the one doing the seven-in-the-morning school runs. I was the one sitting in sterile urgent-care waiting rooms when Toby developed croup. I bought the groceries when Bethany’s fridge contained nothing but expired oat milk and hard seltzers. I paid half her rent three times in the past year alone because she was perpetually “in between opportunities.”
She called me Aunt Sarah when she wanted gratitude for social media photos. She called me cold and selfish whenever I dared to have plans of my own on a Saturday night.
Bethany glanced over Mom’s shoulder, catching my gaze. Her glossy lips curled into an expectant grin. "Looks like you’re going to be busy again, Sarah. We’re gonna need your weekend shift cleared by November."
"No," I said.
The word was quiet, but it hit the room like a sudden drop in cabin pressure.
Mom paused mid-hug. Travis stopped his beer halfway to his mouth. Bethany blinked, her smile faltering into an awkward, patronizing laugh.
"What did you say?" she asked, brushing a strand of highlighted hair behind her ear.
"I said no." I picked up a napkin, gently wiped Toby’s mouth, and stood up. "I’m done raising your children, Bethany."
Mom snapped instantly. Her face flushed a furious, mottled red. "Sarah Jean! Do not ruin this sacred moment for your sister. What on earth is wrong with you?"
"What’s wrong with me?" My voice remained level, though my heart was hammering against my ribs like a caged animal. "I have spent six years giving up my savings, my dating life, my sleep, and my sanity to keep these four alive while Bethany plays house. She doesn’t work. Travis works ten hours a week at a vape shop. And now you expect me to sign up for an infant?"
Bethany’s maternal softness vanished, replaced by the razor-sharp spite I knew all too well. "They’re your family, Sarah! You can’t just abandon them! What kind of sick monster walks out on babies?"
"They aren’t mine," I said clearly. "They are yours. You and Travis made them. You feed them."
Travis pushed himself up from his chair, using his imposing six-foot-two frame to loom over the table. "You got a lot of mouth on you tonight, Sarah. If you don't want to be part of this family, get the hell out of my house."
"Gladly," I whispered.
I grabbed my purse from the back of the chair. Mason looked up at me then, his young eyes filled with a terror that made my stomach twist violently. I wanted to scoop all four of them into my arms and run, but legally, I had no rights. If I took them, it was kidnapping.
"I’m sorry, Mason," I murmured.
"Sarah, if you walk through that door, do not bother coming back!" Bethany shrieked from the hallway. "You’re dead to us! You hear me? Dead!"
I shut the heavy front door behind me, cutting off her screeching.
The cool evening air hit my face like cold water. My hands shook so violently that it took three tries to unlock my sedan. I sat behind the steering wheel, panting, tears of rage and guilt burning behind my eyelids. I backed out of the gravel driveway and drove away.
Twenty minutes later, my phone vibrated in the cup holder.
I pulled over to the shoulder of Route 9, expecting an angry wall of text from my mother. Instead, it was an incoming call from Mason’s restricted smartwatch.
I swiped the screen. "Mason? Are you okay?"
His voice came through as a panicked, ragged whisper.
"Aunt Sarah... Mom and Travis left."
A cold spike of dread shot through my spine. "What do you mean, left? Where did they go?"
"They took the truck," Mason whimpered, fighting back tears. "Mom was screaming that you’d crawl back if you knew we were alone. She locked the deadbolt from the outside and took my front door key. Aunt Sarah... Toby is crying in his crib, and the stove burner is still on. I can’t reach it."
My blood ran ice cold.
Four children. Alone. The youngest was two. The deadbolt locked from the exterior. A live flame on the stove.
"Mason, listen to me," I said, putting the car in drive and slamming my foot on the gas. "Take Chloe and Leo into the back bathroom. Lock the door. Do not open it for anyone except me or the police. Do you understand?"
"Yes, Aunt Sarah."
"I'm calling 911 right now."
I hung up, dialed emergency services with trembling fingers, and made an illegal U-turn across the grass median.
By the time my headlights illuminated Bethany’s street twelve minutes later, two squad cars were already parked in the driveway, their red and blue strobe lights painting the peeling vinyl siding in violent hues. A firefighter had already kicked the front door off its latch.
And just as I threw my car into park, Travis’s lifted black pickup truck came speeding down the road, skidding to a halt behind the police cruisers.
Bethany tumbled out of the passenger side, her face drained of all color. But she wasn't looking at her crying children on the lawn.
May you like
She was staring in absolute, paralyzed horror at the front doorway, where two officers were carrying out a heavy steel lockbox they had just pulled from beneath the floorboards.
***
