forum

Chapter 14 - THE PRE-TRIAL MANEUVERS

Over the next two months, life settled into a new, beautiful rhythm.

Molly returned to fourth grade to a hero’s welcome; her class had made a massive banner that hung across the blackboard reading: *WELCOME BACK, SUPER-MOLLY!* Calvin was invited to join the travel hockey team—a commitment I had never been able to afford before because I was paying Ross’s credit card bills and Evelyn’s condo fees.

With the parasites removed, my bank account flourished.

For the first time in my adult life, I wasn't scrambling to cover surprise five-thousand-dollar deficits or late-notice property tax bills for my mother. I hired a full-time, professional nanny named Maria—a warm, grandmotherly woman with a background in pediatric nursing—who took over the afternoon school runs so I could reduce my hospital hours from eighty a week to forty-five.

Meanwhile, behind the concrete walls of the Cook County jail, Ross Vance was realizing that his charm was useless against the grinding machinery of the American justice system.

On February 20th, Ross’s new private attorney—hired through the remnants of a trust account that Victoria hadn't yet frozen—filed a motion to suppress the balcony security footage, claiming it violated Ross’s "reasonable expectation of privacy."

The hearing was held before Judge Higgins.

I sat in the gallery with Victoria. Across the aisle, Arthur Sterling sat in the second row, accompanied by Julianna and two corporate attorneys.

Ross was brought in wearing an orange jumpsuit, his hands shackled to a belly chain. He had lost at least twenty pounds; his face was hollow, his arrogance replaced by a frantic, hunted look. When he caught sight of Julianna sitting in the courtroom, he mouthed the words: *“I love you. Please help me.”*

Julianna didn’t even blink. She turned her head and looked directly at the judge’s bench.

“Your Honor,” Ross’s attorney, a sleek defense specialist named Harold Vance (no relation), argued smoothly. “The exterior balcony was an extension of the curtilage of the guest suite my client was occupying. The installation of a high-definition recording device without his express written consent constitutes an illegal search under the Fourth Amendment.”

Judge Higgins looked at the defense attorney as if he had just crawled out of a sewer.

“Mr. Vance,” the judge said, her voice dripping with dry acid. “Are you telling this court that an invited guest—who paid zero dollars in rent, who held no formal lease, and who was hosting an unauthorized party in a home owned exclusively by Dr. Lauren Vance—had a reasonable expectation of privacy on an open, exterior balcony visible from the public street?”

“He... he considered it his temporary residence, Your Honor,” Harold Vance stammered.

“The motion to suppress is denied,” Judge Higgins ruled instantly, banging her gavel without hesitation. “The security camera was installed on the exterior facade of Dr. Vance’s property for security purposes. The footage is wholly admissible. Furthermore, the State’s motion to introduce the 911 audio recordings and the forensic hypothermia reports is granted.”

Harold Vance sat down, his face flushed with defeat.

Ross leaned back, his eyes rolling back in his head as if he might pass out.

Beside him, Evelyn sat with her court-appointed lawyer. She had aged ten years in sixty days. Her hands shook constantly, a symptom of the severe anxiety she had tried to suppress with Ambien for decades. She looked at me across the courtroom aisle, her eyes wide with pleading terror.

She mouthed: *“Lauren... I’m sorry. Please.”*

I met her gaze for two seconds.

May you like

Then I looked at my watch, stood up, and walked out of the courtroom to pick up Molly from her ballet class.

***

Related Stories

Other posts