Chapter 7 - The Deposition of Ashley Carter
Word count: ~1,500 words
Two days after the federal arraignment, the climate inside the bureau’s downtown conference room was sterile, bright, and intensely formal.
I sat at the end of the long mahogany table alongside Director Sterling and a federal assistant U.S. attorney named Marcus Vance—unrelated to the defense attorney Arthur worked with, but sharing the same sharp, no-nonsense legal acumen.
Across the table sat Ashley Carter.
She looked entirely different from the smug, champagne-sipping graduate student who had held up my stolen folder at the family dinner table just a week ago. She wore an oversized grey sweater with no makeup, her hair pulled back into a messy ponytail, wringing her hands nervously against the leather armrests of her chair.
Beside her sat a public defender appointed by the court—a tired-looking man named Henderson who had already advised her to cooperate fully with federal prosecutors in exchange for a deferred prosecution agreement.
“Miss Carter,” the assistant U.S. attorney began, his voice flat and clinical. “Do you understand that you are under federal oath, and that providing false or misleading statements during this deposition constitutes a felony offense under Title 18 of the United States Code?”
Ashley swallowed hard, her eyes darting nervously toward me before returning to the prosecutor. ☕ “Yes,” she whispered. “I understand.”
“Let’s establish the timeline of events leading up to last Saturday evening,” Marcus instructed, leaning forward. “State for the record how you obtained access to the restricted federal documents stored inside Agent Michael Vance’s private residence.”
Ashley took a shaky breath, her voice trembling slightly as she spoke into the desk microphone.
“I... I wanted to see if Michael really had the kind of money Mom and Dad always talked about,” Ashley confessed, tears beginning to well up in her eyes. “Mom told me he had a hidden investment portfolio in his home office. She gave me the spare key she kept for emergency plant-watering when he was out of town.”
“And you entered the residence without his knowledge or consent?” Marcus pressed.
“Yes,” Ashley admitted, her voice dropping to a near-whisper. “I unlocked the office door, used the key he kept in the desk drawer to open the locked filing cabinet, and took Folder 404.”
“Did you know at the time that the documents inside were classified federal investigative files?”
“No!” Ashley blurted out quickly, panic flashing in her eyes. “I swear to God, I didn't! I thought it was just private personal banking records! I wanted to use his assets as leverage to pay my graduate school tuition deposit because Dad said his company accounts were tied up.”
I watched her across the table. For a moment, I felt a flicker of pity. She had been raised in an environment where boundaries didn't exist, where rules were suggestions, and where family corruption was masked as clever business acumen. She had simply played the game she was taught to play—only she hadn't realized the board was rigged with federal landmines.
“Miss Carter,” I spoke up for the first time during the deposition, my voice cutting through the heavy silence of the room.
Ashley flinched, looking up at me with terrified eyes.
“When you stood up at that dinner table,” I said calmly, “and announced to twelve members of our family that you had photographed every page ‘just in case I tried to deny it,’ were you aware that those photographs were automatically syncing to public commercial cloud servers?”
Ashley shook her head vigorously, fresh tears spilling over her eyelashes. “No! I didn't know anything about cloud sync settings! I just thought it was like taking pictures of a textbook page! I swear, Michael... I didn't mean to compromise your case. I just wanted to humiliate you so you’d look like a hypocrite.”
Director Sterling leaned back, folding his arms across his chest. “She’s telling the truth, Agent Vance. The cyber-forensic report confirms her digital illiteracy. She had no idea she was handling classified material until you read the indictment headers at the table.”
Marcus consulted a legal pad in front of him, jotting down a quick note with his pen.
“In light of Miss Carter’s full cooperation,” Marcus announced formally, “and given that the compromised data packets were intercepted and scrubbed before reaching external nodes, the United States Attorney’s Office is prepared to offer a deferred prosecution agreement.”
Ashley’s head snapped up. “A... a deferred prosecution? What does that mean?”
“It means no criminal charges will be filed against you,” Henderson, her public defender, explained gently, “provided you complete one hundred hours of community service, sign a strict non-disclosure agreement regarding all federal investigative protocols, and refrain from violating any laws for the next twelve months.”
Ashley stared at the prosecutor, the weight of a federal prison sentence lifting off her shoulders in a single instant. She burst into loud, sobbing tears of relief, burying her face in her hands.
“Thank you,” she choked out between sobs. “Thank you, Michael... thank you.”
May you like
“Don't thank me, Ashley,” I said quietly, gathering my files into my leather briefcase. “Thank your own terrible operational security. If you hadn't taken those photos and bragged about them at dinner, I might never have caught Dad before he scrubbed the servers. In a strange way, your arrogance saved the entire investigation.”
I stood up, buttoned my suit jacket, and walked out of the conference room without looking back.
