Chapter 2 - The Call That Changed the Tone

The autumn rain started around midnight, drumming a steady, restless rhythm against our bedroom window. David was sleeping soundly beside me, his arm draped loosely over my waist, the steady rise and fall of his chest an anchor in the quiet dark. But I was awake, my mind looping through the image of Jace kneeling over that olive-green duffel bag.
“If you unpack, it means you actually think you're staying.”
His words echoed in the silence, a haunting reminder of the invisible trauma carried by children in the foster care system. We could paint his room, buy him clothes, and enroll him in the best local high school, but until he truly believed he belonged here, he was just a guest waiting for his eviction notice.
At 7:14 AM, the kitchen was already chaos.
Josie was sitting at the breakfast island with a bowl of multicolored cereal, her spoon splashing milk onto the quartz countertop while she babbled about a dream she had involving a purple cat. David was packing his briefcase, grabbing his travel mug of black coffee, and trying to locate his car keys.
"Has anyone seen my keys?" David asked, rummaging through the mail holder by the front door. "I have a first-period AP history lecture and if I'm late, Principal Henderson is going to give me that look again."
"They're on the hook by the coat rack, Dad," Jace’s voice cut through the noise.
We all turned. Jace was standing at the entrance of the kitchen, wearing a dark blue hoodie and carrying his backpack over one shoulder. His hair was slightly messy, as if he’d run his fingers through it a dozen times, but he looked alert.
David looked up, spotted the keys right where Jace had pointed, and let out a relieved laugh. "Right where I left them. Thanks, J. You're a lifesaver."
Jace gave a tiny, almost imperceptible nod—that same fractional movement of the mouth I had seen on day one—and walked over to the counter to pour himself a glass of orange juice.
As he reached for the carton, I noticed something different. Something subtle, but significant.
His right hand was empty. The small wooden blue jay, which he usually carried around in his pocket like a talisman, wasn't there.
"Did you forget your little bird?" I asked before I could stop myself.
Jace froze, the orange juice carton suspended an inch above his glass. For a split second, his eyes darted toward the hallway leading to his bedroom, then back to me. A faint, dusty flush crept up his neck, coloring his skin.
"I didn't forget it," he muttered, looking down at the counter. "I put it... on the shelf."
My heart did a quiet, triumphant cartwheel. On the shelf. Not tucked away at the bottom of the duffel bag. Not hidden in a pocket. On the shelf, out in the open, alongside a few books and a framed photograph of the four of us at the local park from two weeks ago.
Before I could say anything else that might make him retreat behind his armor, the landline phone on the wall buzzed.
We rarely used the landline; it was mostly for spam calls and robocalls from insurance companies. David frowned, checking his watch. "Who's calling this early?"
I walked over and picked up the receiver, expecting a recording. "Hello?"
"Is this Katherine Miller?" a voice asked.
It was a woman’s voice, sharp, raspy, and worn down by decades of chain-smoking and too many years inside the bureaucratic machine of child welfare. It had a strange, abrasive edge to it—not the clinical professionalism of Angela, our caseworker, but something far more weathered and urgent.
"Yes, this is Kate," I said, my brow furrowing as I glanced at David, who was watching me with a questioning look. "Who's this?"
"My name is Martha Gable," the voice barked through the static of the line. "I was Jace and Josie’s foster mother for fourteen months before they were moved to that temporary placement in the district. The one that fell through after three weeks."
A cold spike of adrenaline shot straight down my spine. Martha Gable. Angela had mentioned her in passing during our initial orientation—a veteran foster parent who took in older kids when no one else would, known for being tough as nails and utterly lacking in warmth.
"Oh," I said, my voice tightening. "Hello, Ms. Gable. Is everything alright? Are the kids—is there an issue with the case files?"
"The paperwork is fine, as far as I know," Martha said, her tone clipped. There was a pause on the line, the sound of a heavy lighter clicking and a sharp intake of breath, followed by the unmistakable sound of exhaled cigarette smoke. "I’ve been watching the directory. Saw that a couple out in Oak Creek finally took them in. Saw it was you and your husband."
"Yes," I said cautiously, motioning for David to stay quiet. Josie was still chattering away about her cereal, completely oblivious. "We adopted them last month. Everything is... going very well."
"Is it?" Martha let out a dry, hacking laugh that sounded more like a cough. "That’s what they all say at first. The kids are sweet until the walls come down. Then the real fun starts."
My maternal defensiveness flared up instantly. "Jace and Josie are wonderful children, Ms. Gable. We are thrilled to be their family."
"Save the speech for the caseworkers, honey," Martha interrupted, her voice dropping lower, cutting through the pleasantries with terrifying precision. "I didn't call to chat about how well you're adjusting. I called because I wanted to ask you a question."
"A question?" I repeated, my fingers tightening around the plastic receiver.
"Yeah." Martha’s voice turned dead serious, stripping away all the cynical bravado. "I’ve been turning this over in my head for six weeks ever since I heard you two cleared the home study. Out of all the people in this county—out of all the wealthy couples, the church groups, the eager suburbanites who came through that agency looking for a cute little four-year-old girl and ran the other direction the second they saw her brother..."
She paused. I could hear the faint crackle of static and her ragged breathing on the other end of the line.
"They still haven't told you why they picked you, have they?"
The kitchen seemed to go dead silent. Even Josie’s block tower clatter faded into a distant hum.
"What are you talking about?" I asked, my voice dropping to a harsh whisper. "We passed the home study. We chose them."
"No," Martha said softly, and there was a strange, chilling pity in her raspy tone. "You didn't choose them. Jace chose you. And you have no idea what that boy had to do to make sure you didn't walk away like all the rest."
Click.
May you like
The line went dead.
The dial tone droned in my ear, loud and mechanical, while the world around me suddenly felt like it was tilting off its axis.